Live Chat +91-9811561566
#1 Latest Blogs

How Can MSME Lawyers in the Supreme Court Protect Business Interests?

Consult MSME lawyers for Supreme Court matters involving MSEFC awards, delayed payments, arbitration challenges and legal protection for businesses across India.

Get A Free Consultation
Trusted Consumer Legal Guidance
Experienced NCDRC Lawyers
Consumer Court Legal Solutions
Professional Legal Consultation

How Can MSME Lawyers in the Supreme Court Protect Business Interests?

Money might not be the only thing at stake during a dispute between businesses. A manufacturing company may be impacted due to pending invoice payments. They could miss out on employee salaries, purchase of materials and other expenses. In case of buyer, he could lose significant amount of money if awarded under MSME. This could also impact his business by enforcing the award.

Supreme Court MSME Lawyers come into picture when a dispute comes to the attention of Hon'ble Supreme Court of India. They will ensure that your business understands its rights under law. Also they will help you to understand what has been ordered by lower courts and help you challenge the order or seek other remedies.

Supreme Court is generally not the first point of contact for MSME related issues. It could be a contract issue where you may want to negotiate with the other party. You may want to initiate proceedings to recover your dues. Or it could be a matter which came before MSEFC. However if there is any substantial question of law which needs to be answered then the matter can be taken to Supreme Court.

If you are facing issues related to MSME then you should know what options are available to you. Be it recovery of dues, invoices pending against you. Arbitration awards against your business or enforcing such awards. There are various steps you can take.

BK Singh Advocate understands that each dispute has a different scenario. When it comes to MSME Laws. Our MSME Lawyers will look at your situation from both ends. If you are a supplier who wants to recover dues. Or you are a buyer and want to challenge the MSME award.

We understand that each client has different requirements when it comes to MSME disputes. Whether you are located in Delhi, Noida, Gurugram. Mumbai, Bengaluru, Chennai or anywhere else in India. We will be able to assist you under the Micro Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act 2006.

This article will tell you about the MSME Lawyers and how they can help your business in case of a dispute. What remedies are available to you when you go to Supreme Court.

Why Do MSME Disputes Matter in India ?

There are many MSME's that operate in India within the manufacturing, trading and services sector. When payments are held up, contract disputes arise or if the case moves to a recovery suit. This can be detrimental to these small businesses.

Take for example a manufacturing unit that makes machine parts in Faridabad who sells to a bigger customer in another state. If there is a dispute about quality of the product and they hold back the money. Your business would approach the MSEFC. Once there is an award made.

Your customer could appeal against that award. You may have to enforce that award. In case it goes to court you should know what your options are.

If your business operates in Delhi NCR your option could be the MSEFC, district court, High Court and Supreme Court (if required).

BK Singh Advocate will help you understand your case and what repercussions it may have on your business and law.

Quick Facts

Important MSME Legal Provisions
  • Legislation: Micro Small and Medium Enterprise development act 2006.
  • Protection from delayed payment: Sec 15 16 & 17.
  • Disputes: Sec 18 for Conciliation & Arbitration.
  • Challenge against award: Sec 19 where non supplier has to pay pre deposit of 75%.
  • Article 136 allows special leave petition to be filed in Supreme Court.
  • The Supreme court has discretion to hear a matter, this is not a right to appeal.
  • The documents and orders of previous court may help you in your appeal.

What Do MSME Lawyers in the Supreme Court Actually Do?

MSME Advocates deal with disputes arising out of Statutory dues, facilitation council awards and arbitral awards and their appeals.

They don't merely file a petition. They will look into the contract, point out mistakes, previous orders and check if your case falls under any ground that can be considered before Supreme Court.

Buyer may have the view that MSEFC order was made without hearing his contractual grievances or Supplier may be unable to enforce the award due to further proceeding filed by Buyer.

In such cases you would need a Advocate who will go through your records carefully.

BK Singh Advocate believes in finding out what the dispute is and not all commercial disputes should be taken before the Supreme Court.

How Does the MSMED Act Protect Small Businesses?

As per the MSMED Act any qualified Micro & Small Enterprise who supplies to a Buyer can use this Act to their benefit.

Section 15 states that when a buyer has taken delivery of goods or services from a Supplier they shall pay him on the agreed day which can't exceed a maximum of 45 days from the date of receipt or deemed receipt.

Section 16 if payment isn't made within the stipulated time frame. The Buyer will have to pay compound interest at 3x the bank rate notified by RBI with monthly rests.

Section 17 Buyer shall pay the amount as due along with interest calculated as per section 16.

Section 18 allows a person who has a dispute with the amount as payable under section 17 can make a reference to the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council.

Facilitation Council will try to Conciliate the matter. If that doesn't succeed it can either Arbitrate the dispute or refer to a body/institution who offers Alternative Dispute Resolution services.

It will be analyzed whether the above provisions would be applicable to the present facts. Such as registration of M/S Enterprise and supply date/acceptance.

When Can an MSME Dispute Reach the Supreme Court?

Every dispute between MSME's will not be heard by the Supreme Court. There could be other routes available depending upon what type of order has been passed. Where in the litigation you stand and what challenges you can raise.

Below is one example of how things can play out:

  1. There is a commercial dispute between Supplier and Buyer regarding payment of goods/services or any dues which are unpaid.
  2. Supplier files petition before MSEFC under section 18.
  3. Award is passed after Arbitration (if conciliation is unsuccessful).
  4. Award is challenged before the appropriate Court (by the person who is entitled to challenge) as per provisions available to him/her.
  5. Depending upon the order passed by the court and remedies available you may approach the High Court.
  6. You can petition the Supreme Court to grant Special Leave under article 136 if there is something on record.

Just because an MSME's order is challenged doesn't mean that the Supreme Court will entertain your matter. It all depends on what the Hon'ble Supreme Court thinks.

We at BK Singh Advocate can tell you if there is anything on record that may warrant an approach to the Supreme Court.

What Legal Remedies Are Available to MSME Businesses?

The remedy depends on the nature of the dispute and the order being challenged.

Legal route Purpose
MSEFC reference Seeking resolution of qualifying payment disputes
Arbitration proceedings Adjudication after unsuccessful conciliation
Section 34 Arbitration Act application Challenging an arbitral award on recognised statutory grounds, read with applicable MSMED Act requirements
High Court proceedings Seeking an appropriate remedy under its jurisdiction
Article 136 SLP Requesting discretionary special leave from the Supreme Court
Enforcement proceedings Seeking execution of an enforceable award

It should be done after studying the original contract and award and court orders passed thereafter.

An SLP under Article 136 is not an appeal. It is up to the Supreme Court to grant or not grant special leave. Once special leave is granted then it becomes an appeal.

There is a big difference. When you file an SLP you cannot say that Supreme Court will take up the whole question on merit.

What Documents Are Required for Supreme Court MSME Proceedings?

It could be argued that document collection is one of the hardest tasks in Commercial Suits. If invoices and Arbitration proceedings are not available then it may not be possible to identify the amount of the dispute at hand.

There are certain documents that businesses can collect.

  • Udyam registration certificate and other forms of registrations if applicable.
  • Orders, Work Orders and Supply contracts.
  • Invoice copies, Delivery Challan and Goods Received notes.
  • Communication through Email, Demands and Contracts.
  • Ledgers and Bank transactions.
  • Copy of MSEFC Reference and Notices.
  • Records of Conciliation and Arbitration Proceedings.
  • Arbitration Award or Council Order.
  • Petition under section 34 and Judgements.
  • Orders of High Court and Interim orders (if any).
  • Workings and Proof of Payments.

These documents can be arranged by BK Singh Advocate to form a proper case file to be analyzed by your lawyer.

Also remember that all previous transactions may not be covered by your Udyam registration. It depends on the date of registration and what was provided by your vendor.

When Should You Consult an MSME Lawyer for Supreme Court Litigation?

If you wait till the execution is done you may be left with very less time to figure out what you can do.

You should seek legal opinion if;

  • MSEFC has awarded your company.
  • The pre deposit amount is hampering your finances.
  • High Court has dismissed your plea.
  • There is a problem while executing the award by a vendor.
  • If there are contractual/statutory issues which can be raised against the award.
  • In case of large amount of money involved or issue is repeated.

In Delhi NCR(Noida, Ghaziabad,Faridabad and Gurugram) we can help you find out what council to approach or if the court will entertain your plea.

We at BK Singh Advocate can advise you if you should litigate the matter further or require help with execution or any other legal remedy.

How Can BK Singh Advocate Help MSMEs With Supreme Court Matters?

Businesses should know their legal position as well. Even if you feel you have a valid defence against a claim you may suffer financially till the time the matter is decided upon.

At MSME Lawyers we represent companies who require legal aid against unpaid dues and statutory claims. As well as Arbitration and other related matters.

BK Singh Advocate can help you with:

Know where you stand

We will look at your agreements, payments and any awards/orders passed to determine if your case is tenable.

Filing in the Supreme Court

Can we file an SLP or what other options do you have? We will study the records of the case.

MSEFC Award

Do you have any valid objections under the statute. Arbitration or Sec 19 issues.

As a supplier

Are your dues being held up? Statutory Interest. Issues pertaining to execution.

As a buyer

If there are any objections to invoices or agreement. Can we challenge the award. What will be your loss.

Before going to High Court or above

We can study the matter to see what remedies are open to you.

As lawyers we understand that a company needs to know how much it will cost to proceed with a case. And what to expect. Every case is different when it comes to litigation.

There is no guarantee that your case will succeed in the Supreme Court. It all depends on the facts of your case.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Are MSME Lawyers allowed to appear before Supreme Court?

Yes they can if the professional requirement is met for representing a client in Supreme Court. You would have to follow Supreme Court Rules and Advocate on Record as well. BK Singh Advocate will be able to help you with this.

2. Can MSME supplier go to Supreme Court for unpaid dues?

Supplier can take action against buyer as provided under MSMED act which includes taking action before MSEFC. Which in turn could be taken to the Supreme Court if required under article 136.

3. What is section 18 MSMED act?

Section 18 deals with dispute resolution before the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council. Whereby the dispute can be conciliated and arbitrated if conciliation is unsuccessful.

4. Is 75% Deposit mandatory in all MSME cases?

No. Section 19 deals with applicant who is not a supplier and wishes to take action against award or order. He will have to deposit 75% of the amount involved. This will depend on your case.

5. Can Buyer take action against MSEFC award?

Yes. Buyer can challenge the award before appropriate court subject to section 19.

6. Can Supreme Court stay the MSME award?

Supreme Court can give appropriate relief if required. This will depend upon your case. You cannot get stay just because you filed an SLP.

7. What is an SLP in MSME?

SLP stands for Special Leave Petition. Which you file before the Supreme Court asking them to allow you to appeal against the order passed by court or tribunal.

8. Can MSME cases be settled?

Yes. If both parties wish to settle then they can lawfully do so. Make sure the settlement contains all details regarding payment.

9. Do MSME lawyers work outside Delhi?

Yes. We can help you if you are a business from any other state in India. BK Singh Advocate will guide you further on this.

10. How can I speak to BK Singh Advocate about my MSME Supreme Court issue?

You can reach out to MSME Lawyers with your agreement and invoices and any MSEFC or Court orders. BK Singh Advocate will review your documents and let you know what options you have.

Final Thoughts

An MSME Dispute could have consequences on your business after you have closed the deal. Invoice payments pending, Arbitration award or Court cause your business to suffer.

MSME Lawyers at Supreme Court will guide you through various options available on appeal. To evaluate your case and place it before the appropriate forum.

Reviewing your documents and previous order should be the first thing you do. Once you have properly evaluated your position it will be beneficial to go through litigation again.

At BK Singh Advocate we aim to educate businesses about there MSME issues under the current act.

If you are a Supplier / Buyer / Manufacturer etc who may require urgent assistance regarding your MSME issue speak to a professional.

Author Bio

BK Singh Advocate belongs to the MSME Lawyers which deals with all type of cases regarding Micro Small Medium Enterprises throughout India. Such as delayed payments, MSEFC proceedings, Arbitration Awards, Commercial recoveries and its appeals. We analyse the agreements and MSMED act 2006 to provide the best solution for your case in the court of law or Tribunal. If you need legal help in Delhi NCR, New Delhi and any commercial hub of India. You can contact us for MSME proceedings and cases. Including the Supreme Court of India.

There's no reason for concern. There is no difficult-to-understand legalese.

Someone who has helped many people with the same problems gives you clear, honest advice. We want to make the legal process easy to understand and use for everyone.

 +91-9811561566 Chat on WhatsApp