Outstanding invoices are a common headache faced by small businesses. Whether it is supply of goods as per PO, services rendered for a job or contract completed - it can take weeks or even months before the purchaser pays and provides a legitimate reason for delay. This is more than just a book-keeping entry for small businesses. Outstanding receivables impact cash flow to meet staff costs, pay other vendors, service borrowings etc and constrain ability to take on further projects. Many small businesses will not pursue legal recourse due to the perceived loss of goodwill/customers from the buyer or prolonged relationships. They continue to issue follow-ups/demand letters to the buyer. However, demand letters may prove futile. If significant sums of money are outstanding from buyers, it would be beneficial to engage the services of an advocate to ascertain one's legal rights and explore alternative avenues of debt recovery. An advocate well-versed in matters concerning MSMEs can review the terms of trade, outstanding dues and determine whether the claim is amenable to a proceeding under the MSMED Act 2006. One may approach BK Singh Advocate for an opinion on claims arising on account of delayed payment from buyers after assessment of available records and information. The MSMED Act makes specific provision to remedy non-payment/late payment to registered Micro & Small enterprises. This is therefore a useful tool that can be invoked to recover amounts due from defaulting purchasers. Nonetheless, a uniform remedy is not necessarily available for all instances of unpaid invoices. This would depend on various factors including MSME registration, timing of sale of goods/provision of services, terms of the contract, documentary trail and the defences advanced by the buyer. MSME Lawyers endeavours to assist businesses in navigating these concerns and exploring alternative means of recovery in relation to debts due by purchasers. Appropriate advice at the earliest opportunity can assist the business to transition from sending demand letters to initiating a claim in accordance with its merits and circumstances, having regard to the relationship with the buyer and any attendant implications of litigation. Micro and small businesses are engaged in a wide range of activities including - manufacturing, trading, professional, IT, transport etc. throughout India. It is often critical to them to receive regular and timely payments from their principal customers / clients. Consider a manufacturer based in Noida supplying goods to its buyer in Gurugram; or a service provider based in Delhi rendering services to its client in Mumbai; or yet another sub-contractor based in Ghaziabad having rendered services to a main contractor and not able to realise the payment on account of sanctioned bills. In the event of non-receipt/delayed receipt of payments, they may not be able to procure material, pay their staff and/or continue to take up fresh jobs. This can significantly impact the business if they have availed OD / working capital lines from banks to fund their day-to-day operations. Therefore, realisation of payments from due and overdue amounts against sanctioned bills by MSMEs is important in view of the provisions of the MSMED Act 2006. Depending on the location of such MSMEs (e.g. Delhi NCR, UP, Haryana, Maharashtra, Karnataka, Telangana etc.), it would be necessary to ascertain the competent Facilitation Council. Given that most B2B transactions span across states, choosing the appropriate Forum for recourse cannot merely be done on the basis of expediency. BK Singh Advocate can help analyse the particular transaction in light of the MSMED Act and advise the available means of payment recovery. This requires scrutiny of documents establishing the due amount and entitlement under the MSMED Act. MSME payments recovery refers to the recourse(s) open to a micro/small enterprise who has provided goods / services to a purchaser and is seeking payment therefor. Such recovery could be through settlement/amicable discussion, referral of the claim to MSEFC or arbitration/litigation as applicable to the circumstances. Accordingly, the key question that arises is if a payment is due to the supplier and what recourse should the MSME adopt for its recovery. Assume a Micro/Small enterprise provides goods to a customer to the extent of INR 12 Lacs against a valid PO. The purchaser fails to make payment and raises certain issues with respect to the goods after some time. Herein, it would be relevant to ascertain whether the goods have been duly received by the customer, if the issues are bona fide & raised within the appropriate time, the amount payable and if the MSME is eligible to approach the MSEFC. MSME Lawyers can help identify such differences in a case and advise on the next steps to be taken by the client. While it may be prudent to first explore discussions with the other party before making any claim, there are cases where it will be necessary to take formal action. An MSME Lawyers can advise on whether there is an applicable statutory provision, if the claim is sufficiently evidenced through invoicing and whether the appropriate court/forum is seized with jurisdiction. This will also allow for identifying deficiencies in contract terms, ahead of them being raised as defences. It is important to consider these points at the outset as non-payments frequently involve additional allegations. These could include: faulty/non-conforming goods, deficiency in service, short-delivery, levying of extra charges or deductions made in prior months. This will enable a more objective assessment of the merits of the dispute and whether any withholding of payment is warranted. MSME Lawyers can support MSMEs in collating relevant information about the supply and transacting relationship, considering their respective obligations and the implications that may arise. In circumstances where payments continue to remain outstanding, BK Singh Advocate can provide input as to the prospects of success in respect of the outstanding payment claim. Ultimately, it enables an MSME to take an appropriate next course of action in the matter. The Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council allows businesses to make references for certain dues owed by buyers, provided the claim is admissible and falls within its purview (s.18 of the MSMED Act). Thereafter, the reference can be conciliated and/or arbitrated as the case may be. It is desirable that the supplier knows the due owed, period during which goods/services were supplied, the terms of payment, and if any objection/plea has been recorded by the purchaser in this respect. Details regarding the supplier and when it attained the prescribed status may also be pertinent. An online platform for MSME ODR has been created by the Government (in addition to the existing Samadhaan portal) to receive and process such references. Under the scheme notified by the Government, it allows for online filing, tracking, serving of notices, discussion and adjudication of cases. Reference may be made to the applicable mode as per the prevailing guidelines when lodging the reference. BK Singh Advocate can guide a supplier to determine the appropriate forum and collate the facts for making a reference / appear before the authorities concerned. Once a reference is accepted by the Facilitation Council, it can be sent for conciliation/arbitrated directly at a conciliation / arbitration centre/institution. In the absence of a settlement, the dispute would be taken up for arbitration pursuant to the provisions of the MSMED Act. Pursuant to s.18(5), a decision on a reference is required to be rendered within 90 days from the date of reference. The provision sets out a timeframe, but may not be possible to conclude all matters within that period. In most cases relating to commercial dues and payments, documentary proof will go a long way. Even if the seller feels the purchaser is in evident arrears towards them, the seller would need documentation to substantiate its case. Such records generally include (not limited to): We at MSME Lawyers can also support you in evaluating your available documentary trail and appreciate the implications of certain points of contention. Where there are several bills raised, a duly reconciled statement can aid to segregate the amounts that remain outstanding and those that may have already been netted off. If invoices continue to remain unpaid after due dunning, the purchaser keeps deferring the date of payment or large amounts remain outstanding, adversely impacting the business, it is advisable to seek legal opinion. Legal advice would be appropriate if there is any challenge against the works performed by you, possible cross claims from the purchaser, or demand for compromise/compounding. Lack of clarity on applicability of Udyam certificate to your business, disputes with respect to terms of payment, question of limitation etc. may also require legal opinion. Do not rely on continuing discussions/negotiation with the debtor to keep the claim alive indefinitely. You may seek the opinion of BK Singh Advocate to understand if there is a case for taking legal recourse against the defaulting party, or if the matter can be amicably closed through written negotiation. This may also help to avoid wasteful legal costs if it is determined that there is inadequate material to substantiate your claim. In many cases, mere issuing of a Legal Notice is not sufficient for businesses to recover amounts due from customers/trade debtors. A detailed review of contract terms, statutory provisions, supporting documents, commercial viability and legal remedies is required. At MSME Lawyers, we assist businesses looking to resolve their dues, trade receivables / outstanding payments, trade disputes and other issues falling within the scope of MSEFC. This would typically include review of purchase/credit notes & other transactional documentation, buyer's grievances, negotiating an amicable closure and exploring legal courses available under various laws of the country. Mr. BK Singh can be reached out on issues such as unpaid/delayed payments, preparation of recovery notes, award of interest and appropriate legal recourse. Clients from Delhi/NCR (Noida, Gr. Noida, Ghaziabad, Gurugram, Faridabad) and other parts of the country may evaluate their legal position based on the circumstances and governing forum/jurisdiction of the deal. We would aim to provide practical legal counsel and advice to arrive at a workable solution, and will refrain from over-promising recovery of dues. An experienced MSME lawyers will review the outstanding bills, relevant contract documents, establish applicability of the statute to your transaction and advise on further steps available to you. You may approach BK Singh Advocate who can advise you on taking the dispute to negotiation or Facilitation Council, or initiating any other remedy. If the amount due from a business counterparty falls within the ambit of legal recovery, then an MSME lawyers can assist to initiate steps towards its recovery. Recovery will however depend on multiple factors such as your legal entitlement, facts and documentation, buyer's defences, enforceability etc. There can be no assurance of recovery of any amount. Micro and Small Enterprises, to the extent the provisions of the MSMED Act apply, are entitled to claim interest on delayed payments at the rate stipulated under s.16 MSMED Act i.e. compounded monthly, at three times the bank rate notified by the RBI from time to time. While you would need an active Udyam registration to initiate the special mechanism available under the MSMED Act for recovery of overdue payments, it would be necessary for a lawyer to examine the dates of your Udyam registration vis-a-vis the transaction to establish your eligibility. As per the MSMED Act, the special procedure under Chapter V is available to Micro & Small Enterprises only. Medium Enterprises cannot invoke the benefit of this provision. However, there may be other means open to the Medium Enterprise to seek recovery of overdue amounts. It is possible to resolve the matter amicably with your counterparty via communication and negotiations leading to payment/settlement. Alternatively, if the conditions are met, you can refer the dispute to the Facilitation Council. Your MSME Lawyers will guide you on the suitability of resolving the matter out-of-court. Under s.18(5) MSMED Act, a reference before the Facilitation Council is to be decided within 90 days of initiation of the proceeding. Depending on the facts of the matter, the number and pendency of disputes, objections from the buyer etc., this period may be extended, or give rise to further proceedings. If the buyer has legitimate grounds to reject the goods/services on the basis of contractually agreed parameters, they may be able to avoid their obligation to make the payment. A MSME Lawyers would be well placed to scrutinise both the buyer's and your claims. Yes, you may take a legal advice from a MSME Lawyers based in Delhi NCR, irrespective of your location. You may seek the assistance of BK Singh Advocate to advise you on your pending payments, subject to the appropriate jurisdictional Forum for Facilitation Council being identified and a representative appointed. The professional charges will depend on the value of the dispute, quantum of work required, need for consultations/appearances, legal filing charges etc. We recommend you take adequate clarity on these costs and terms of engagement prior to retaining a lawyer. Late payments have the potential to adversely impact the functioning of legitimate and going-concern enterprises. It is advisable that suppliers do not simply wait to be paid at the discretion of buyers. They should document their dues, assess their entitlement under the MSMED Act and be apprised of the courses of action available to them. Appointing an MSME lawyers will allow them to determine the merit of their case and choose the appropriate forum/authority to approach, while avoiding errors of practice. A team of MSME Lawyers can support you if you wish to take assistance on your business receivables/late payment. You can contact us (BK Singh Advocate) directly for advice in specific circumstances after we have reviewed your documents. Prompt action with regard to due diligence will ensure you are in a strong position to recover your dues and have reasonable expectations from the relevant forum or enforcement authority.
Why Should You Hire an MSME Lawyers for Business Payment Recovery?
Why MSME Payment Recovery Matters in India
Quick Facts About MSME Payment Recovery
What Is MSME Payment Recovery and How Does It Work?
Why Should You Hire an MSME Lawyers Before Filing a Recovery Claim?
How Does MSME Payment Recovery Work Through the MSEFC?
Ascertainment of the Due
Reference and its scrutiny
Conciliation and Arbitration
What Documents Are Required for MSME Payment Recovery?
When Should a Business Consult an MSME Payment Recovery Lawyer?
How Can MSME Lawyers Assist With Delayed Business Payments?
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why engage an MSME lawyers in respect of unpaid amounts?
2. Will my business payment be recovered if I retain an MSME lawyers?
3. Am I entitled to receive interest on overdue payments from a business?
4. Do I require an Udyam Registration to initiate recovery of dues from a business?
5. Can I initiate a reference before the Facilitation Council if I am a Medium Enterprise?
6. Is it possible to seek recovery without instituting litigation?
7. What is the expected timeline to complete an MSME payment dispute?
8. My buyer alleges defects in goods/supplied products. Are they not required to pay?
9. Can I approach a MSME Lawyers if my business is based outside Delhi NCR?
10. What will I have to pay to a lawyer for pursuing my business payments?
Final Thoughts
There's no reason for concern. There is no difficult-to-understand legalese.
Someone who has helped many people with the same problems gives you clear, honest advice. We want to make the legal process easy to understand and use for everyone.